Riporta ad un Moderatore • Board Game Arena

Tutti i resoconti

Terra Mystica resoconto

#13203: "Dwarves cult spades should not give VP"

fixed: L'errore è stato corretto

A che riguardo è la segnalazione?

Terra Mystica #55889897

Cos'è successo? Prego, seleziona tra le seguenti

Regole: una regola del gioco non è stata rispettata

Cos'è successo? Prego, seleziona tra le seguenti

Regole: una regola del gioco non è stata rispettata

Si prega di verificare se esiste già una segnalazione sullo stesso argomento

Se sì, per favore VOTA solo questa segnalazione. Segnalazioni con più voti hanno priorità di presa in carico!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Descrizione dettagliata

Storico dei resoconti

9 Aug 2019 03:17 • firexed • L'errore non è stato ancora riprodotto dagli sviluppatori:

See 1st reply here :

boardgamegeek.com/thread/1645000/bonus-landscapes-rules-questions

9 Aug 2019 11:45 • diamant • L'errore non è stato ancora riprodotto dagli sviluppatori:

Appendix VI: The Factions : "Get 4 Victory points each time when Tunneling." (about the Dwarves)

This is not debatable. The point is that you cannot do Tunneling with cult bonus spades.

The rule explicitly states page 15 (printed in red) :
(Neither may the Fakirs do a Carpet Flight, nor the Dwarves
do Tunneling when getting Spades as a Cult bonus. A Carpet
Flight and Tunneling have costs that cannot be paid outside the Action
phase. Also, if the Giants get only a single Spade as a Cult
bonus, this Spade will be forfeit.)

At move #273 (Terra Mystica #55889897), the implementation incorrectly proposes to transform terrain spaces which are not adjacent to a dwarf structure, because no additionnal cost can be spent during this phase (III), like worker for the Dwarves, priest for the Fakirs.

It is therefore also necessary to check whether the mentioned rule is respected in the case of Fakirs and Giants, and to correct all related bugs.

10 Aug 2019 05:28 • firexed • L'errore non è stato ancora riprodotto dagli sviluppatori:

Diamant - Wrong. The dwarves' special landscape lets you tunnel to spend cult spades, you just don't get VP for them. See the rules

10 Aug 2019 10:56 • diamant • L'errore non è stato ancora riprodotto dagli sviluppatori:

Fixered, you didn’t properly describe the bug, and that’s the only reason I didn’t consider the special landscape rule.

You are wrong when you assert that :
"The dwarves' special landscape lets you tunnel to spend cult spades, you just don't get VP for them." This is not the rule, nor specifically the rule for the Great Tunnel.

I fully understand that the allocation of 4VP for Tunnelling, while the Dwarves spend no workers, generates an excessive advantage for this faction, but you do not provide any evidence that this should be the rule.
There was certainly a lot of discussion about special landscapes with different or even contradictory opinions. An opinion is not a rule.

13 Aug 2019 14:16 • Een • Sono richieste più informazioni dagli sviluppatori per riprodurre questo errore:

Not sure what an official answer on this would be. It's not in the landscape rule pdf and the bgg thread answer you refer to is not from Feuerland or the game designer. Does anyone have a link to an authoritative answer on this?

18 Aug 2019 11:02 • firexed • Sono richieste più informazioni dagli sviluppatori per riprodurre questo errore:

The reply by DocCool in the link in my post that they shouldn't get VP was thumbed up by the game designer (Horologiom) so it is likely to be correct.

3 Jun 2020 21:13 • skrohmagnon • Sono richieste più informazioni dagli sviluppatori per riprodurre questo errore:

The rules p15 are clear. This is a bug on BGA. It must be fixed as soon as possible.

28 Jun 2020 12:41 • Anadh • Sono richieste più informazioni dagli sviluppatori per riprodurre questo errore:

The fact that landscape combined with bonus spade could give VP is up to debate.
But the fact that once your great tunnel is in the game you don't pay workers for any additional spade should only be true within a 2 hex range of the great tunnel.
On table=97427723, move #308 we can clearly see the dwarf player:
- use one of his free spade out of range of the great tunnel without paying the workers
- get the 4VP bonus twice, once for that dig, and once for the dwelling he puts down a couple of moves later.
Something's not right.

29 Oct 2020 14:23 • Calmon70 • Sono richieste più informazioni dagli sviluppatori per riprodurre questo errore:

I also notice this in my game:
boardgamearena.com/1/terramystica?table=118440119

The dwarf player used tunnels with cult spades and got 4 VP without paying any workers. This should never be the case - either you can't tunnel with cult or you can tunnel but it should cost you workers.

14 Nov 2020 17:34 • Neviron • Sono richieste più informazioni dagli sviluppatori per riprodurre questo errore:

There are PDF rules provided in the game, and mouseover tooltips, which state for the special landscape of the dwarves:
"With the Great Tunnel as the starting point, the Dwarves may Tunnelthrough2 Terrain spaces instead of just 1. Every time they get Spades as a Cult Bonus, they may Tunnel to spend these Spades (and not paying Workers for that Tunneling)."
I would expect that dwarves can tunnel for spades generated through cult-bonus, without paying a working and still getting 4VP - ONCE AND ONLY IF they have built the special landscape. This is clearly stated in the rules. Am I reading it wrong, or is there an official errata changing it?

-> Please implement the games according to the rulebooks provided. Our player "Tieftaucher" had to pay 1 worker to tunnel with the cult-spades in this game: boardgamearena.com/gamereview?table=123912414, and therefore didn't (she expected it to be free).

18 Nov 2020 21:23 • Rincevent123 • L'errore è stato confermato dagli sviluppatori:

I PMed Helge Ostertag on BGG to ask hum, here is his answer:

it is true, they shouldn't get the 4 vp's if they use the landscape ability with cult spades to tunnel and spade. The rule is actual meant like this: the dwarves now can tunnel cult spades in general (not only from the special landscape) without paying workers, but they don't get vp's for that.

20 Nov 2020 11:05 • Rincevent123 • L'errore è stato corretto:

issue is fixed

3 Jan 2021 14:12 • canetts • L'errore è stato corretto:

FYI. Bug is fixed (workers are not consumed), but prompt text still tells you it will use workers. Apologies, I didn't take a screenshot

Aggiungi qualcosa a questo report

Aggiungi qui tutto ciò che sembra pertinente per riprodurre questo bug o capire il tuo suggerimento:

Un altro ID tavolo / ID mossa
F5 ha risolto il problema?
Il problema si verifica spesso? Ogni volta? Casualmente?
Se hai una schermata di questo errore (cosa buona e giusta), puoi usare Imgur.com per caricarla e fare copia/incolla del link qui.

Annulla Aggiorna report

#13203: "Dwarves cult spades should not give VP"

A che riguardo è la segnalazione?

Cos'è successo? Prego, seleziona tra le seguenti

Cos'è successo? Prego, seleziona tra le seguenti

Si prega di verificare se esiste già una segnalazione sullo stesso argomento

Descrizione dettagliata

Storico dei resoconti

Aggiungi qualcosa a questo report

Cambia il resoconto di status in:

Aiuto

Dona

Naviga

Seguici